Green Consumer Behavior – Part II: Evolving Social Norms toward the Environment

Joel Makower’s recent blog entitled “Is ‘Carbon Neutral’ Good Enough?” speaks to the growing trend to offset carbon emissions generated from personal or business activities.  Consumer sentiment is changing in the US, with a growing consensus on the need for action to mitigate global warming.  As Makower points out, companies such as DHL and UK-airline Silverjet have recently launched new services that include carbon offsets into the price, while TerraPass, Kärcher USA and Sam’ Club announced the first carbon-balanced retail product.  In fact, as Makower notes, carbon neutral “is rapidly becoming a minimum expectation of companies, concerts, conferences [and] celebrations.” 

Marketers should take note of this emerging trend and its underlying motivations: when it comes to global warming, social norms are evolving.  Quite simply, it is becoming less and less acceptable for companies not to take responsibility for their own (or their customers’) carbon emissions. 

The notion of carbon responsibility first became popular on the global stage in relation to leisure and non-essential business activities.  Examples include global sports events or conferences.  Recently, it has spread to corporations that anticipate the inevitability of government caps on carbon (if not governed by them already), as well as to consumers who are increasingly conscious of their own responsibilities and frustrated by the inaction of their own governments. 

Academic literature addresses this impact.  In his Focus Theory of Normative Conduct, Cialdini et al (1990) suggest that social norms influence acceptable and unacceptable behaviors.  He identifies two types of social norms: 

  • Descriptive norms: “what [other] people typically do”
  • Injunctive norms: “what [other] people typically approve or disapprove [of]”

Only by aligning descriptive norms…with injunctive norms,” Cialdini et al proposed, “can one optimize the power of normative appeals.” 

Cialdini presents empirical evidence for his theory and how it impacts environmentally responsible behavior.  In one experiment, he tested the propensity for people to litter given different social norms and cues.  Results demonstrated the power of the descriptive and injunctive norms for littering: people displayed a higher propensity to litter when the environment dictated litter as the norm (e.g. there was more litter on the ground or others were observed littering) and a lower propensity to litter when it was clear cleanliness was the “approved” norm (e.g. after observing someone else litter within a clean environment).  

One could argue that similar dynamics are in play when it comes to action (or inaction) on global warming.  In this case, at least until very recently within the US, the prevailing descriptive norm was to do nothing, because that is what everyone else was doing. 

Two things are occurring that seem to be changing this.  First, descriptive norms within the global community apprear to be evolving.  These norms have shifted more dramatically in Europe and Japan and provide tangible examples for the US to follow.  Some initial signs of change have appeared: 1) US multinational companies have joined the Chicago Climate Exchange and committed to voluntary carbon reductions, 2) state and local governments have enacted sweeping legislation to cap carbon emissions and 3) individual consumers are purchasing an increasing number of higher gas mileage vehicles. 

Second, injunctive norms are also changing as global social norms shift toward responsibility for carbon emissions.  Much like the smoking ban enacted in 2003 in New York City, which is credited for inspiring similar bans globally, global social norms are shifting in regard to global warming.  As Al Gore stated in his movie, we have a “moral responsibility” to take action – and it seems that we are slowing beginning to do that. 

So, marketers should take note.  Campaigns should take advantage of – as well as reinforce – evolving social norms and do so in a way that incorporates both descriptive and injunctive norms into their messaging.

References

Cialdini, Robert, R Reno, and C Kallgren, 1990. “A Focus Theory of Normative Conduct: a theoretical refinement and re-evaluation of the role of norms in human behavior.”  Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, 24, 201-234 

Cialdini, Robert, 2003. “Crafting normative messages to protect the environment”, in Current Directions in Psychological Science, 12-4, 105

20 Responses to Green Consumer Behavior – Part II: Evolving Social Norms toward the Environment

  1. danlewer says:

    Hi David – thanks for the post. Who do you think leads the evolution of social norms?

  2. Auto companies which gives attention to the clean air act are admirable. A lot new car models uses diesel, which is safer to use that it emits lesser toxins. Others like the GM fuel savers are also invented helps, due to less fuel emissions. Also, it can help minimize the expenses of the vehicle owners for the rising price of the gasoline…

  3. Carol Battle says:

    I think alot of the challenge is in educating and motivating people to help the changing social norms. Guilting people only freezes them into inaction – there’s already enough guilt!!

  4. maycee says:

    lol an hirap basahin eh kain n lng kayo bubog.
    ..do you know what is bubog??.. its like a jelly kind thing but the different is that bubog is hard to eat than jelly..

    ..i have another question too!!.. ..if you are a great marketer, answer this:
    …if you are a CACTUS…… ……WHY??………………

  5. Mr. Allan christian V, Lopez says:

    ..ehm, hi to all!.. ..if you want to change the environment, it all start in you!. ..everything starts in us. The great power you have the greater responsibility. If you want to do what is right, Sometimes, we give up what we want the most!!..even if it is our dreams!..thanks^_^

  6. Speeding help in Scotland…

    Ask a specialist lawyer a free question in confidence. Can we share information and best practices?…

  7. I agree as what Mr. Allan stated, environmental changes start within our self. We people should know how to conserve everything. It is our home so we should work together on it.

  8. Some really interesting details you have written. Assisted me a lot, just what I was searching for : D.

  9. I discovered this site through Google and I enjoy the data here. I have added the RSS and will definitely be back in the future. Keep writing!

  10. Let me help you withWriting articles…

    […]Green Consumer Behavior – Part II: Evolving Social Norms toward the Environment « Marketing Green[…]…

  11. My website says:

    My website…

    […]Green Consumer Behavior – Part II: Evolving Social Norms toward the Environment « Marketing Green[…]…

  12. cardiac sonography schools in illinois…

    […]Green Consumer Behavior – Part II: Evolving Social Norms toward the Environment « Marketing Green[…]…

  13. reward says:

    reward…

    […]Green Consumer Behavior – Part II: Evolving Social Norms toward the Environment « Marketing Green[…]…

  14. inspired says:

    inspired…

    […]Green Consumer Behavior – Part II: Evolving Social Norms toward the Environment « Marketing Green[…]…

  15. uhaul says:

    Hello to all, the contents existing at this web site are in fact amazing for
    people experience, well, keep up the nice work fellows.

  16. Heya are using WordPress for your blog platform? I’m new to the blog world but I’m trying to get started and set up my own.
    Do you need any html coding expertise to make your own blog?

    Any help would be greatly appreciated!

  17. Asking questions are in fact pleasant thing if you are not
    understanding anything fully, however this piece of writing presents good understanding yet.

  18. One is tgat it speeds up thhe access to the internet.
    India’s worries that Pakistan, by insefting itzelf
    in the centre of an international extra-legal detention system.
    Gumtree is a heavily trafficked free anonymous proxy server sight, andd with nno your understanding
    constantly pass on the dat to ouur Computer system.
    In the end, the state, and your laptoop computer isn t widxe open for you
    to get IPs.

  19. 20 body fat says:

    This page definitely has all of the information and facts I wanted concerning this
    subject and didn’t know who to ask.

  20. Hey there! Quick question that’s completely off topic. Do
    you know how to make your site mobile friendly?
    My site looks weird when viewing from my iphone 4. I’m trying to find a template or plugin that might be able
    to correct this issue. If you have any suggestions,
    pplease share. Thank you!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: