Consumer Misperceptions Regarding Energy Efficiency

A recent survey published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences indicates that consumers are misinformed about how best to realize energy savings.  Marketers have the opportunity to make a significant impact on energy use by filling in knowledge gaps, correcting misperceptions and helping consumers prioritize actions that generate the greatest impact.  (Attari et. al., “Public Perceptions of Energy Consumption and Savings” August 2010)

As Attari et. al. point out, consumers can typically realize greater energy savings through structural improvements in energy efficiency (e.g., switching to fluorescent light bulbs) than from behavior changes that curtail energy use (e.g., turning off lights).  Yet, more than half of survey participants held the mistaken view that behavior changes such as turning lights off (nearly 20%) or reducing driving/biking/taking public transportation (15%) were likely the most effective way to reduce energy.  By contrast, only 12% of participants pointed to a structural change such as use of efficient light bulbs (4%) or appliances (3%).

Attari et. al., also explored consumer perceptions regarding the relative potential for energy savings through behavior changes or structural improvements in low and high energy intensive devices (e.g., heaters), appliances (e.g., cloth dryers) or activities (e.g., washing clothes at a lower temperature).  Interestingly, survey participants systematically underestimated the energy use and savings potential from energy-intensive options – with actual energy use or savings potential nearly 3x consumer estimates.  With little knowledge or reference points to make an informed decision, participants seemed to rely on heuristics like “anchoring” to make educated guesses regarding the impact of appliances and devices relative to a more familiar one, the 100 watt bulb. 

Such survey results should not come as too much of a surprise to most utility marketers, as consumers have traditionally lacked a detailed understanding of their energy bill and options for mitigating it. 

For marketers, such a knowledge gap provides a clear opportunity to engage consumers across new dimensions by:

Providing more details regarding household energy use: Consumers would take more action if they better understood the impact that each appliance, device and activity had on their aggregate bill.  While smart meter deployments make providing this level of transparency a snap, marketers may be able to improvise by providing likely usage patterns extrapolated from consumers with similar historic consumption patterns or surveys.

Leveraging more relevant heuristics: Marketers should focus on dollars rather than kilowatt hours of energy saved.  Money is more easily understood by consumers, especially when comparing products and product investments across categories.  For more significant investments, provide a personal return on investment or payback period to facilitate consumer decisions.

Benchmarking individual energy use against the community: Whenever possible, utilities should provide comparative data regarding personal energy use relative to the average in a community.  Such social marketing may provide an added level of urgency to act for consumers who use more energy than their neighbor (though marketers must take care in their messaging so as not to promote added energy usage by those already using less than the average).

Partnering to extend reach: Utilities should partner with others also interested in selling more efficient appliances and devices including retailers and OEMs, as well as those that interact with consumers at key trigger points for purchase such as real estate brokers, mortgage brokers and contractors. Such arrangements are mutually advantageous and can greatly extend reach and amplify messaging in market.

About these ads

12 Responses to Consumer Misperceptions Regarding Energy Efficiency

  1. Nice, substantive post as usual, Dave. Found the finding about consumer behavior as superior to using energy efficient appliances curious, but possibly explainable by logic: behavior associated with shutting off a lightbulb or whatever altogether, while using energy efficient appliances still continue to use electricity.

    Am in total agreement about opportunity to underscore primary benefits. Energy Star so successful because it links to a direct consumer benefit such as money savings—versus FSC for instance which provides more of an altruistic benefit. I include more details about all of this in my upcoming book, The New Rules of Green Marketing (http://www.greenmarketing.com/our-book)

  2. dwigder says:

    Thanks Jacquie,

    You are correct that structural changes are typically more effective than behavior changes. Participants surveyed apparently held misperceptions regarding what actions would have the greatest impact. I clarified the post to make it clearer. Thanks for your comments. I look forward to reading your book.

    Best,

    David

  3. [...] to David at Marketing Green for finding this survey! This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink. [...]

  4. [...] –Be careful when making claims about energy efficiency. There is a growing backlash towards companies that over-claim energy efficiency. [...]

  5. Have you ever considered about adding a little bit more than just your articles? I mean, what you say is fundamental and everything. Nevertheless think about if you added some great photos or video clips to give your posts more, “pop”! Your content is excellent but with images and videos, this blog could definitely be one of the greatest in its field. Good blog!

  6. article submissions…

    Consumer Misperceptions Regarding Energy Efficiency « Marketing Green…

  7. Rocket Signs says:

    We do Signs, Printing, Branding and More

    Cape Town and the Western Cape’s most comprehensive and Innovative Sign and Signage company. Good Signage can provide direction, answer questions, informs and warns. It is a useful form of advertising and is often the first point of communication with any potential client.

  8. Writing For Money…

    [...]Consumer Misperceptions Regarding Energy Efficiency « Marketing Green[...]…

  9. Used Citroen says:

    Used Citroen…

    [...]Consumer Misperceptions Regarding Energy Efficiency « Marketing Green[...]…

  10. new Jaguar for sale in KZN South Africa…

    [...]Consumer Misperceptions Regarding Energy Efficiency « Marketing Green[...]…

  11. Used Kia cars…

    [...]Consumer Misperceptions Regarding Energy Efficiency « Marketing Green[...]…

  12. real estate in Loxahatchee Florida…

    [...]Consumer Misperceptions Regarding Energy Efficiency « Marketing Green[...]…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 60 other followers

%d bloggers like this: